Puzzle Maker Pro alternative: how the free DT Labs generators compare
Pick Puzzle Maker Pro if you work on Windows and want specialist logic puzzles and detailed control: it lists 60+ puzzle modules, batch runs and interactive outputs, with most modules we read at $47 to $177 or everything for $97 a month. Pick DT Labs generators if the common puzzle types cover your book, or you are on a Mac: they run in a browser, also make mandala coloring pages and planners, and are free to make and preview, with clean files in DT Labs Membership.
We make DT Labs generators, so weigh this page with that in mind and check the sources at the end. Facts about Puzzle Maker Pro were read from its own site on 9 November 2026.
How do Puzzle Maker Pro and DT Labs generators compare?
| Feature | Puzzle Maker Pro | DT Labs generators |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Per module, most $47–$177 in the part of the store we read; Everything Monthly $97/month; Everything Unlimited Yearly $970/year. VAT or GST added where applicable | $0 to make and preview with a free account, no card; clean files without a watermark are part of DT Labs Membership |
| Payment model | The site describes one-time licences and subscriptions on different pages; shown per product | Free account to make and preview; DT Labs Membership, monthly or yearly, for clean files |
| Try before paying | Free demo: watermarked, one puzzle at a time | Free account: every maker and a full preview; exports are watermarked. Membership has a 30-day refund on the first payment |
| Refunds | Sales are final; the vendor directs buyers to the demo | Nothing to refund on the free account; DT Labs Membership has a 30-day refund on the first payment |
| Where it runs | Windows desktop software; Mac needs a virtual machine. Generation does not need internet | Web browser, with a free account |
| Puzzle range | 60+ modules, including sudoku variants such as killer and jigsaw, 2D and 3D mazes, codeword, word ladder, nonogram, Masyu, Yin Yang, Galaxies, pentomino, quiz builder | Word search, sudoku (incl. Sudoku X and Samurai), crossword, cryptogram, maze, kakuro, nonogram, dot-to-dot, mathdoku, bimaru, bingo |
| Coloring and planners | No coloring book or planner generator found on the pages we read | Mandala coloring pages and an undated planner maker |
| Answer keys | Saved as separate files; book layouts can collate solutions or print cross-references | Answer pages made with each puzzle |
| Puzzle checks | No statement found | A solver confirms each sudoku has exactly one solution; each maze has exactly one path |
| Page size | Set by you | 6×9, 8×10, 8.5×8.5 and 8.5×11 in for KDP; US Letter, A4, Half Letter and A5 for printables. No custom sizes |
| Export | JPG, PNG, transparent PNG at 300 or 96 DPI; some modules SVG or XML; books as PDF or PowerPoint; interactive PDF on Interactive editions | PDF or 300 DPI PNG pages; watermarked on a free account, clean with DT Labs Membership |
| Batch | Time Saver runs many setups in one go (Productivity edition) | Whole book in one export, clean with Membership |
| Watermark | Demo output watermarked; paid output is not | On free-account exports; none with DT Labs Membership |
| Commercial licence | Paid licences; home page names Amazon KDP, Etsy, Teachers Pay Teachers and your own store. Separate tiers for reseller and PLR use | Sell on KDP, Etsy or your own shop; you may not resell or share the generator |
What does a working set of modules cost?
Puzzle Maker Pro is priced per puzzle type, so the total depends on how many you buy. Most of the module prices we read fell between $47 and $177. Five modules would come to $47 × 5 = $235 at the low end and $177 × 5 = $885 at the high end. Exact prices per edition were not in the text we read, and we read the first 20 of 221 store products.
The all-in plans are simpler to work out. Everything Monthly comes to $97 × 12 = $1,164 a year. Everything Unlimited Yearly is $970, a difference of $1,164 − $970 = $194.
DT Labs generators are not sold per puzzle type: a free account opens every type listed above with watermarked exports, and clean files are part of DT Labs Membership (price at dtlabs.app/pricing). Whether a Puzzle Maker Pro purchase is one-time or recurring depends on the product, because the site describes both, so read the product page before you pay.
What does Puzzle Maker Pro do that DT Labs generators do not?
For a puzzle specialist, Puzzle Maker Pro goes much deeper. These are the areas where it does more:
- A far longer puzzle list: 60+ modules, with specialist logic types such as Masyu, Yin Yang, Mosaic, Galaxies and pentomino
- A Windows app where generation does not need internet
- Page size you set yourself, plus control over layouts, fonts and per-puzzle settings
- Batch runs across mixed settings on the Productivity edition
- Interactive PDF, Puzzle Slides and web play on Interactive editions
- Separate rights for supplying puzzles to other publishers
- SVG or XML output on some modules, and books as PowerPoint
What do DT Labs generators do that Puzzle Maker Pro does not?
Our makers are simpler and cover a smaller puzzle list, with a few differences that matter for a first book.
- They run in a browser, so Windows is not required
- Every puzzle type listed is included on a free account, with no modules to buy
- Mandala coloring pages and a planner maker with 24 page types, which we did not find on its pages
- A KDP checklist in the maker for page count, margins and gutter, which we did not find on its pages
- A stated solver check on sudoku for exactly one solution
How do the licences differ?
Puzzle Maker Pro has more licence classes because it serves more kinds of publisher. Its terms describe a Personal / Low Content licence for print-on-demand books on Amazon or Etsy, where customers may not resell the puzzles, and a Reseller / PLR class for supplying puzzles for others to resell. The Productivity edition adds the right to supply generated puzzles to other publishers. Its pages differ in wording, so check the product page and terms for the specific module.
DT Labs generators have one licence: sell what you export on KDP, Etsy or your own shop, with no attribution or royalty. It does not cover reselling or sharing the generator.
Who is Puzzle Maker Pro a good fit for?
Puzzle Maker Pro fits puzzle-book publishers on Windows who want many specialist puzzle types and detailed control. Because sales are final, try the free demo first and confirm the modules you need.
Who is DT Labs generators a good fit for?
DT Labs generators fit sellers who want the common puzzle types, coloring mandalas or planners with no installation and no modules to buy: free to make and preview, with clean files in DT Labs Membership. If you need Masyu, killer sudoku or a custom page size, our makers do not offer them.
Frequently asked questions
Does Puzzle Maker Pro work on a Mac?
No, it is Windows software, and a Mac needs a virtual machine to run it. DT Labs generators run in a web browser.
Is Puzzle Maker Pro a one-time payment?
It depends on the product. Its home page describes a one-time licence, its product page describes monthly or yearly subscriptions, and its Purchase Information page says each product shows which applies. Check the product page before you buy.
Is there a free version of Puzzle Maker Pro?
There is a free demo, which is watermarked and limited to one puzzle at a time. We found no statement on selling demo output.
Can I sell what I make with Puzzle Maker Pro?
Yes, on a paid licence. Its home page names Amazon KDP, Etsy, Teachers Pay Teachers and your own store. Licence classes differ, so check its terms for the module you buy.
Do I need a separate module for each puzzle type?
Yes, unless you buy a bundle or an Everything plan. It is sold per module, in Base, Creative and Productivity editions.
Can I get a refund on Puzzle Maker Pro?
No, its terms say sales are final, and it directs buyers to the free demo. Subscriptions can be cancelled at any time, with access to the end of the paid period.
Does Puzzle Maker Pro make coloring books or planners?
We found no coloring book or planner generator on the pages we read. DT Labs has a free mandala maker and a free planner maker.
Is there a free alternative to Puzzle Maker Pro?
Yes for common puzzle types. DT Labs generators are free to make and preview with an account; exports are watermarked, and clean files with a commercial licence are part of DT Labs Membership. They have far fewer specialist puzzles.
Sources
- BookPublisherTools home page: positioning, licence wording, puzzle types, read 9 November 2026
- Puzzle Maker Pro: platform, formats, subscription wording, read 9 November 2026
- Editions and demo limits, read 9 November 2026
- Book workflow and batch runs, read 9 November 2026
- Store: per-module price ranges, read 9 November 2026
- Everything plans: prices and rights, read 9 November 2026
- Nonogram module: edition rights, offline generation, read 9 November 2026
- Purchase information: refunds and payment, read 9 November 2026
- Terms: licence classes and refunds, read 9 November 2026
- DT Labs generators: price and features
Puzzle Maker Pro is a trademark of its owner. DT Labs is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Puzzle Maker Pro. Prices and features can change, so check each product's own page before you buy.