Novelcrafter vs ShadowPress: two tools that run on your own AI key
Pick Novelcrafter if you want to stay in control of every scene, with a detailed Codex, planning grids, many AI providers or a local model, and no genre restriction that we found, for $8 a month or more on AI plans. Pick ShadowPress if you want a fixed, staged route from idea to full draft of a thriller, mystery or kids' spooky novel for $0 plus your own OpenRouter usage. In both, you pay your AI provider separately.
We make ShadowPress, so weigh this page with that in mind and check the sources at the end. Facts about Novelcrafter were read from its own site on 9 November 2026.
How do Novelcrafter and ShadowPress compare?
| Feature | Novelcrafter | ShadowPress |
|---|---|---|
| Price (US view; prices are localized) | Scribe $4/month (no AI); Hobbyist $8; Artisan $14; Specialist $20 | $0 for the tool, free for every DT Labs account |
| AI usage | Paid separately to your chosen provider, unless you use free or local models | Paid separately to OpenRouter |
| Try before paying | 21-day trial with all features and no card | No trial needed for the tool |
| AI connections | Anthropic Claude, OpenAI, OpenRouter, Groq, Anyscale, LM Studio, Ollama and any OpenAI-compatible service | OpenRouter only |
| Local models | Supported | Not supported |
| How drafting works | Writer-led: you generate prose from your own scene beats, with prompts and models you choose | Staged: premise, twist plan, cast, chapter outline, clue or safety check, then chapters; a button writes all chapters |
| Story knowledge | Codex with aliases, tags, relations, progressions, tracking and mentions | Cast and plan stages for each book; a series bible across books |
| Planning views | Grid, Matrix, Outline, scene labels and custom POVs | Editable chapter outline |
| Custom prompts | Custom prompts, prompt components and prompt preview | Fixed prompts; you can add a rewrite instruction |
| Genres | No genre restriction found | 11 preset genres in two families: thriller, mystery and horror; and kids' spooky |
| Chat with your novel | Artisan and up | Not included |
| Team use | Invites and teams on Specialist | Not included |
| Import | Word, Markdown, HTML and Apple Pages | None; a book starts from an idea |
| Export | Word .docx or Markdown, with guides for Atticus and Scrivener | TXT, Markdown, EPUB, a print interior in 4 KDP trim sizes and an Etsy printable edition |
| Refunds | Terms leave refunds to its discretion, with 14 days given as an example; its billing help routes requests in the first 14 days through Paddle | Nothing to refund for the tool |
| Output ownership | Its Terms say your content, including AI-generated content, stays yours and it claims no rights over it | Our Terms say you own the content you upload and the outputs you generate, and you are responsible for them |
| Track record | Began in 2023 by its own account; active blog, newsletter, Discord, YouTube and free courses | Added to DT Labs in October 2026 |
What does each one cost over a year?
On monthly billing, Novelcrafter Hobbyist comes to $96 a year ($8 × 12), Artisan to $168 ($14 × 12) and Specialist to $240 ($20 × 12). Scribe comes to $48 ($4 × 12), but it has no AI features. A yearly option is labelled "2 Months off"; the exact yearly amounts were not in the page text we read.
ShadowPress comes to $0 a year for the tool ($0 × 12).
The AI bill is the part both share. Novelcrafter can connect to OpenRouter, so a given model is priced the same in either tool. What differs is the tool fee and how much text each one sends to the model as you work.
What does Novelcrafter do that ShadowPress does not?
Novelcrafter is a full writing environment that happens to use AI. ShadowPress is a much narrower drafting pipeline. Novelcrafter does more in these areas:
- A Codex that tracks characters and details with progressions and mentions, shared across a series
- Planning views: Grid, Matrix, Outline, scene labels and custom POVs
- Many AI providers and local models, where ShadowPress uses OpenRouter alone
- Custom prompts you can write and preview
- No genre restriction that we found, and a guide for romance, where ShadowPress has 11 presets in two families
- Importing a manuscript you have already started
- Team invites, free structured writing courses, a Discord community and a history going back to 2023
What does ShadowPress do that Novelcrafter does not?
ShadowPress makes the structural decisions for you, in a set order, for two kinds of book. That suits someone who wants a finished draft to edit rather than a workspace to write in. Novelcrafter says of itself that it is built to help writers write, not to write a book in one click.
- A twist plan and clue check for thrillers, and an ending-first plan, scare ladder and safety check for kids' books
- Word and chapter targets set by reader age, from early readers to adult
- One button to write every chapter
- EPUB, a print interior in 4 KDP trim sizes and an Etsy printable edition, where Novelcrafter's guides send you to a formatting tool
- A listing kit with title ideas, blurbs, keywords and categories
- No monthly fee for the tool
Who is Novelcrafter a good fit for?
Novelcrafter fits writers who like detailed planning and story-bible tools, want to write scene by scene with AI help, and are happy to choose their own provider and model. The 21-day trial with no card is long enough to find out.
Who is ShadowPress a good fit for?
ShadowPress fits KDP and Etsy authors who want a guided draft of a thriller, mystery, horror or kids' spooky book and do not want a monthly tool fee. It works only through OpenRouter, it has far fewer planning tools than Novelcrafter, and every draft needs a human edit before publishing.
Create a free account for ShadowPress
Frequently asked questions
Is Novelcrafter free?
No, its FAQ says there is no free plan. It offers a 21-day trial with all features and no card, then plans from $4 a month, with AI features from $8.
Is there a free alternative to Novelcrafter?
ShadowPress is $0 for the tool, and you still pay OpenRouter for AI usage unless you use its rate-limited free router. It has far fewer writing and planning tools than Novelcrafter and only covers thrillers, mysteries, horror and kids' spooky books.
Does Novelcrafter include AI, or do I need an API key?
On its AI plans, you connect your own provider and pay that provider for usage. Scribe, the $4 plan, has no AI features.
Can I use OpenRouter with both?
Yes, Novelcrafter documents an OpenRouter connection, and ShadowPress runs only on an OpenRouter key.
Can I use local models?
Novelcrafter supports local models, for example through LM Studio or Ollama. ShadowPress does not, because it works only through OpenRouter.
Can I write romance or fantasy with ShadowPress?
No, its genres are limited to thriller, mystery and horror presets and kids' spooky books. Novelcrafter has no genre restriction that we found, and it publishes a dedicated guide for romance.
Can I export from Novelcrafter to Atticus?
Yes, Novelcrafter exports Word or Markdown and has guides for moving a draft into Atticus and Scrivener. ShadowPress exports EPUB and a print interior itself.
Who owns what these tools produce?
You do, according to both companies' terms. Novelcrafter's Terms cover AI-generated content by name, and the DT Labs Terms make you responsible for what you publish or sell.
Do I have to tell KDP if I use AI?
Yes, if the content is AI-generated: KDP requires publishers to disclose AI-generated text, images and translations. It does not require disclosure of AI-assisted content, so check which applies to how you used the tool.
Sources
- Novelcrafter pricing: plans, trial, FAQ, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter features, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter: 2023 origin and team, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter Terms: ownership, refunds, cancellation, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter billing help: refund route, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter docs: AI connections, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter docs: export formats, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter docs: OpenRouter connection, read 9 November 2026
- Novelcrafter FAQ: AI cost, read 9 November 2026
- KDP content guidelines: AI disclosure, read 9 November 2026
- DT Labs Terms: ownership of outputs, read 9 November 2026
Novelcrafter is a trademark of its owner. DT Labs is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Novelcrafter. Prices and features can change, so check each product's own page before you buy.